My Family Tree

In the 1881 census record for Elizabeth and George there were three additional children named Livingston, Boyd, Catherine and David. Boyd and Catharine were born before Elizabeth and George's marriage, and do not appear in later records; David, born in 1872, was possibly their son. No previous marriage was found for either Elizabeth or George, and while Elizabeth might have had one child before her marriage, 3 seems a stretch.

In the book History and Stories of Clyde River, David's dates were 1872-1873, but David was with the family in the 1881 census - unless this was a mistake and he should have been William Boyd, also born about 1872, who was missing from the household in that census but who appeared in other records as a member of this family.

A son David was not named in George's will, or in Elizabeth's obituary. Eva Livingston Hyde's obituary only named William as a brother who predeceased her.